Tags
antisemitism, fear, Hamas, Israeli flag, Judaism, Palestinians, Sarasota, Zionist
Inside my car are two small Israeli flags, “flying” from poles made of drink straws that are stuck in a vent on the dashboard. They are visible from outside the car, but barely.
I believe in Israel’s right to exist, which makes me a Zionist. But many Americans disagree with me. And because they seem bent on proving that they’re right and I’m wrong through violent means, I am afraid. And so I fly my little flags, but discreetly.
I don’t think people in the pro-Palestinian movement understand what a Zionist is and what it means to me. I think — I’m not certain, but I think this is correct — they believe Zionism means getting rid of the Palestinians, preferably by genocide. To me, being a Zionist means I support having a Jewish state in the ancient Jewish homeland. But it does not mean that I support the Israeli government. An important distinction that is perhaps too subtle for people chanting slogans.
I don’t really know what the protesters believe. I watched the coverage of the protests this spring, listened to their chants, and read the signs. “Lesbians for a Free Gaza”? Do they know how lesbians and gays are treated in majority Arab countries? I wonder if they would feel safe in Gaza.
I worry that when they go back to college this fall they will go back to protesting. I worry that the critical thinking skills that they are supposed to be developing in college are not being applied, and they are simply accepting Hamas propaganda.
And I cynically wonder if they truly care about suffering, downtrodden people. Because if they did, they’d be shouting about suffering around the globe, and they wouldn’t be taking a summer vacation from their protests.
Most of all, I worry that these protests are a smokescreen for antisemitism, pure and simple.
According to a recent article in The New York Times, “Supporting Palestine has become a core feature of progressive politics on many campuses…Accompanying this shift, on campus and beyond, has been a rise in Israel-related antisemitism.”
Before October 7, I naïvely believed that America was a safe space for Jews. I still feel that way in my little city on the edge of the Gulf of Mexico. It’s a tourist town, a jewel amidst a string of jewels that dot the coastline, with beautiful beaches, lots of restaurants, and an inviting downtown. It’s the kind of place where you can go into a fancy restaurant wearing shorts and flip-flops, because the tourists don’t always bring dressy clothes.
I love it here, and I do feel safe, and even cherished by the supportive non-Jewish community around me. But I still fly my little flags discreetly.

The sad aspect of all this, is the fact that the responsibility for what is taking place stated is a result of decisions taken by Britain, France and the UN in 1947. The creation of Israel was against the wishes of the Palestinians and was forced on them
The festering sore created has broken out on occasions ever since, the gulf between the two sides has widened and the religious aspect has made matters worse.
Those of the Jewish faith, Christians and Muslims all lived together on this land many years ago, so one has to ask, why can’t they now?
The answer is simple; religion, politics and outside interference, if America butted out, we might, just might, get some resolution to this mess.
LikeLike
I would say that the saddest aspect of all this is that 6 million Jews were murdered in Europe, and subsequently every Muslim/Arab country kicked more than a million Jews out on their homes. With nowhere to go they went to Israel, their ancient homeland.
LikeLike
The death of the six million by Germany is without doubt a blot on humanity. But few if any had ever been to Palestine,so were not forced of the land now known as Israel. To use as an excuse, the actions of a European government 80 years ago, for what is happening now, fails any logical test or rational thought process.
LikeLike
But you’re happy to use as an excuse events that happened 77 years ago, also engineered by European governments? Remember, Britain ruled the area (before that the Ottoman Empire). I think part of what bothers me is that people are unconcerned that Jews literally had almost nowhere to go. And, as I mentioned, they were expelled from Arab countries in droves beginning in 1948, where nearly a million Jews had lived for generations. Any discussion of returning their land, homes, property? No. Cynically, I believe the world doesn’t care. The difference is that Israel absorbed them, while the Arab world urged the Palestinians to stay in refugee camps.
LikeLike
Thank you. I am heart-sick at what has happened at my alma mater – Columbia and in many other places. I stand exactly where you stand – for Israel, but a new government is desperately needed! And, what about the hostages? I think these kids are pawns in a situation that they really don’t understand. Where is the outrage about Oct 7 and the hostages?
LikeLike
This is a message with which the majority of us can agree – thank you and Shabbat Shalom. Am Yisrael Chai 🙏🇮🇱 💙💛 – Roberta Berson
LikeLike