I never loved Sparky. I took in the 15-year-old Yorkie for six weeks because he needed a place to stay. But the six weeks stretched to six months, until this morning when he died in my arms.
Six months ago his owner’s daughter suggested just putting him down. So I took him to my vet, who said that he was clearly a hospice case, but wasn’t ready to go yet. So I kept him.
I never fell in love with him; to be honest, I never had the inclination. But I cared for him just as I care for my own two dogs (both of whom were rescued from shelters).
A few weeks ago, I wrote this about him: He’s just an old, smelly dog. Not someone’s beloved mother or handicapped child. He has no potential. In the general scheme of things, he simply doesn’t matter. So, on the grand scale of life and our purpose here on earth, do all my efforts on his behalf really matter?
The answer is yes, of course it matters. Not because of the dog but because of me.
I’m that person. The one who cares even when I don’t want to. Who avoids conflict like the plague. Who truly believes, despite all indications to the contrary, that people are inherently good. Who thinks that an icky little dog deserves to be treated with kindness, just as does every person.
The difference with Sparky is that my normal boundaries were dissolved. As a rabbi, I often find myself behaving in a loving manner, regardless of whether or not I love the person. I’m happy to be supportive and helpful, and lend a listening ear. Then I can go home and, if I need to, turn off the phone.
Not so with a dog living in my home. I bought him special foods, walked and bathed him, took him to the groomer and the vet, bought a carrier so he could come on walks when he no longer could walk on his own. I listened to him snore at night and cleaned up his messes in the morning.
This morning, I wept while my vet gave him three successive shots to end his life. I knew it was time; I’d watched him go into a steep decline over the past weeks until his quality of life had nearly vanished. I hesitated last night when he seemed pretty peppy on our walk, but on the way home he couldn’t manage to go any further and had to be carried.
People like to say that dogs wait by the rainbow bridge for their owner to join them. Sparky won’t be waiting for me. There’s a 93-year-old woman in a nursing home far away who bought him as a puppy. She loved him dearly for many years and still yearns for him. They’ll be happy to see each other.
As for me, I will settle back into my old routine with my two dogs, both of whom are seniors. Me too. I joke that we are a geriatric household.
I don’t regret taking Sparky into my home and my life. Yes, it was hard. This morning was awful. And other things happened in that six months — including a disastrous job experience — that challenged me.
But I learned so much. About my tolerance for disruption, about my ability to deal with hard decisions and unreliable people. About my willingness to take on difficult tasks that need doing.
And I learned to love an unloveable dog and weep as he died.

Beautiful writing and sad story. But Sparky got some special time and you got to love and care. In tital good things.
LikeLike
you are such a very special person, Rabbi Jennifer, you have such an amazingly large heart, I have tears in my eyes after reading this posting. How you were able to continue to do so many difficult things and to them so well is definitely a very special gift that you were given. May you continue from strength to strength and may you find love and companionship to keep you going forward.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you Lea. This means more than you know.
LikeLike
Jennifer:Thank you for this heart-breaking post. Sparky was so lucky to find you and his owner would be so touched th
LikeLike
I’m so sorry, Jennifer, th
LikeLike
Thank you for this – and other – columns!
Over the years I had three shelters dogs, stuck with them to the end (one 15 1/2, the other 12 1/2). Those last months were painful as we knew what was ahead. The day we went to the vet, to say goodbye, is right at the top of my most painful experiences. I clearly understand.
Wendy
>
LikeLike
My other two are also rescues, also classified as seniors when I adopted them each at 7 1/2. Now they’re 11 and 12. It’s so different when you chose each other and then lived together for years.
LikeLike
Dear Rabbi Jennifer,
We are so sorry to hear about Sparky. We hope there are smiles through your tears as you remember all the moments he made you furrier, funnier and happier. We understand what it is like to lose a pet who is a member of your family and it is difficult. Our thoughts and prayers are with you.
Also, hopefully, this new year will bring you happiness in your professional and personal lives.
Shabbat Shalom, Selma and Ken Bitz
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you so much.
LikeLike