Tags
This weekend I’ll begin teaching Hebrew school in a sixth grade classroom, Sunday mornings and Wednesday afternoons. I’ve been a pulpit rabbi in an older congregation for quite some time, and I haven’t taught kids in years. I’m nervous, but I’m also looking forward to it.
A recent phone conversation with a woman I barely know took me by surprise. I had mentioned my new position in passing and was changing the subject when she interrupted me.
“Wait a minute,” said the woman. “Weren’t you a rabbi?”
“I still am a rabbi. And now also a Hebrew school teacher,” I replied.
“Why?” the woman asked.
“Why not?”
“Because you’re a rabbi.”
Days later, the conversation still troubles me. What’s wrong with a rabbi teaching Hebrew school?
I retired from my pulpit at the end of 2022. Not ready for full retirement, I took a position as interim part-time rabbi at a local synagogue.
I’ve also been tutoring b’nai mitzvah students for another synagogue, so when they asked me to teach their sixth grade class this fall, I said yes.
The woman on the phone seemed to think that it’s beneath a rabbi to take a “lowly teaching position.” But I don’t feel any less of a rabbi when I’m teaching 12-year-olds. Quite the opposite.
A rabbi is a spiritual leader in a community. But at its most basic, the word rabbi means teacher. If I never lead a service again, I will always be a rabbi.
If I’m lucky enough to make even a small difference in these young people’s lives, they will be learning to be joyously Jewish. I want to help them discover the beauty and power of Jewish prayer and the Hebrew language. I want them to learn that Judaism isn’t the synagogue, it’s the way they think and behave. That they can carry it with them wherever they go, whoever they become.
Yes, I’m nervous. And I’m also grateful for this opportunity. What could be more important??

In our small congregation in VT the Rabbi has always been the force behind the Hebrew School and teacher of the older children. What a blessing you will be to these children and their families. 6th graders are ready for the conversations about how Judaism relates to the world around them in everything they say and do. How wonderful for them and for you! Wishing you Shana Tova Umetukah!
Karen Gartner
LikeLike
Feh! People sometimes say stupid things. Teachers should be lauded at the highest level. They change lives often!
LikeLike
I believe JTS ordains Conservative rabbis as “teacher and preacher in Israel” Isn’t every rabbi at core a teacher?
LikeLike
Yes! Exactly right.
LikeLike
Well said! I am going to forward it to my rabbis at Temple Emanuel in Newton, MA and perhaps a few others. Shabbat Shalom, Ruth Gold
LikeLike
Very well said!!! I am going to forward this to my rabbis at Temple Emanue lin Newton, MA …Ruth Gold
LikeLike
You’ll be great. Enjoy it!
LikeLike
No need for you to be nervous. You’ve been there before I know that from personal experience. When I grew up we had a Rabbi as a Hebrew School teacher. He was terrific. I also learned a lot from my grandfather, also a Rabbi. Your knowledge and dedication does not only come from a title. All the best Joe shoes
LikeLike
You were there with me back in the day!!
LikeLike
As you know, lots of rabbis teach Hebrew school—many of us love to! lol hakavod for doing so!
LikeLike
the children should be honored to have the time to interact with a rabbi. awesome. sometimes people can’t appreciate a great opportunity.
LikeLike
Congrats on teaching 6th grade. You’ll be terrific and give the kids an opportunity to relish Judaism. Rabbi’s teach young and old wherever they are.
LikeLike
For some reason this doesn’t let me post a comment.
I love your comment – please send me the name and address where you are a part-time rabbi 💕.
Elaine
LikeLike
Thank you! It posted. It’s the Jewish Congregation of Venice, 600 N. Auburn Rd.
LikeLike
That woman is misguided. Rabbi = teacher. Young people will benefit greatly from your knowledge and experience. So glad to hear that you are keeping busy! Best of luck with your “new” position and in the coming year, rabbi.
Be well.
Michael H. Fienman, Esq. Attorney & Counselor at Law 1608 Walnut Street, Suite 900 Philadelphia, PA 19103-5451
215.839.9529 – direct 215.405.2699 – fax
michael@forgoodlaw.com
http://www.philadelphiacriminalattorney.com/
IRS CIRCULAR 230 DISCLOSURE: Pursuant to Treasury Regulations, any tax advice contained in this communication (including any attachments) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used or relied upon by you or any other person, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code, or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any tax advice addressed herein.* *
LikeLike