Tags
faith, Gaza, God, Hersh Goldberg-Polin, Jacob's ladder, Judaism, Rachel Goldberg-Polin, Viktor Frankl
“The journey does not unfold as he imagined.”
This is a line from an email I received from the Steinsaltz Center. It refers to the biblical patriarch, Jacob, and this week’s Torah portion.
But at this moment in the story, he is not a patriarch. He is a young man running away from home, after tricking his father and stealing his brother’s blessing. He is fleeing to a new life on a journey that is entirely his own.
When we are young and first leave home, we imagine how our lives will be. We have dreams and hopes, plans and visions, anticipating how our lives will unfold before us.
And like our forefather Jacob, many of those hopes and dreams will not happen quite as we imagined. If we are lucky, they will not be destroyed, but merely changed, redefined, perhaps redirected.
This week I’ve been thinking about Hersh Goldberg-Polin and his dream. He was kidnapped from the Nova music festival on October 7, 2023, and held hostage in a tunnel under Gaza for 328 days before being murdered along with five other captives. He was 23 years old.
Hersh planned to travel the world. As a young boy, he wanted to learn every country in the world and every capital.
His mother Rachel wrote in Time Magazine, “Hersh was a curious, radical listener who dreamt of quenching his wanderlust by traveling the world. He had planned and saved for many years. His ticket was purchased, and the flight date was Dec. 27, 2023. Alas, Hersh was to miss the flight because he was still being held hostage.”
His parents spoke in Sarasota this week. Rachel Goldberg-Polin seems to be overflowing with pain, and I wasn’t sure that I would be able to bear it.
But I joined 1,700 others to hear Rachel and Jon interviewed for an hour, and although there were moments when tears ran down my cheeks, I found their words to be rich with hope and faith.
Listening to them, I found myself thinking about Jacob, and about the uncertainty that lies at the heart of his encounter with God.
One thing has always troubled me about Jacob’s story. After he dreams of angels going up and down a ladder stretching from earth to heaven, and then receiving the most extraordinary blessing from God, he qualifies his response.
He says, “If God will be with me, and will keep me in this way that I go, and will give me bread to eat, and garments to put on, so that I come back to my father’s house in peace; then shall the Lord be my God.”
If.
In many translations, the word appears three times.
Moments before, the Torah tells us that God had promised him, “Behold, I am with you, and will keep you in all places where you go, and will bring you back to this land; for I will not leave you.”
Why then does Jacob say “if”? Does he not trust the promise that the Divine had just given him? Is he so cynical that he must have proof of God’s promise?
One commentator referred to Jacob’s response as being filled with raw human emotion. Jacob was quite literally on the run. He had no idea of what lay before him. All he knew was that while in a dream state, he had received lavish, beautiful assurances of a wonderful future.
But how could he be sure? He had just hurt his brother deeply and lied to his father. Could it be that he feared that he didn’t deserve God’s promises?
Hersh Goldberg-Polin’s parents learned after his death that he had been known among the other captives for quoting Viktor Frankl. Frankl, a Holocaust survivor, had quoted Nietzsche, and Hersh echoed them both: “Those who have a why to live, can bear with almost any how.”
I need to pause and acknowledge that Hersh did not live to follow his dreams, to live his why. He was murdered in a tunnel underground, far from life and light.
Knowing our why cannot guarantee that our dreams will be fulfilled, or that we will survive every hardship. What it can do is give meaning to the way we live. To today.
I think that at this early point in the narrative, Jacob did not yet have his why. He knew what he was running from, but he had no idea what he was running toward.
He had yet to form a vision of who he wanted to be, how he wanted to live in the world, and what he might accomplish.
And a person’s why can be complex. Jacob’s story is about struggle, responsibility, family, reconciliation, and becoming Israel.
I never met Hersh Goldberg-Polin, and I have yet to read his mother’s book. But if I had to guess, his why was a boundless love of life, inextricably linked with curiosity and a yearning for adventure. These attributes combined give him the strength to be a source of comfort and support to his fellow captives.
Hersh’s journey did not unfold as he imagined. Neither did his parents’. Neither did Jacob’s.
And neither will ours.
We cannot know whether our dreams will survive the unexpected turns of our lives. And we know that faith in God will not protect us from suffering.
Knowing our why can sustain us when the journey becomes difficult. When life throws impossible situations our way. When we feel unprepared for an unknowable future. Even when we are suffering.
And we may discover something sustaining in the midst of a journey we would never have chosen.
This is where Judaism gives me sustenance. It does not ask us to deny grief, or pretend that suffering has a purpose. It allows us to mourn, to feel the full weight of sorrow.
But it also reminds us that even in grief, there is room for joy. For hope. For love. And for faith that God is with us.
Jacob awakened from his dream and declared, “Surely God is in this place, and I, I did not know it.”
This is our legacy. The journey does not unfold as we imagined. And yet, for now, on this day, the journey continues.

I created The Jewish Open Tent to continue to pursue my why — to offer Jewish learning that is accessible, open hearted, and filled with joy. I hope you will join me.
Go to https://jewishopentent.com to learn more.
Beautiful
LikeLike
BRAVO….I’m with you!
LikeLike